Google’s so-called “choice screen” for Android just went live in Europe. This means that new Android devices will let their users choose their default search engine during the set-up process. This would be great if there wasn’t a catch. Only search engines that pay Google will be displayed.
Android users deserve to choose their favorite search engine. Google’s decision to sell that choice to the highest bidders is unethical and anti-competitive. Therefore, I announced that Ecosia would boycott this auction.
We didn’t participate in the paid auction (and still don’t) for various reasons.
Ecosia is a not-for-profit search engine. Taking part in Google's auction would force us to spend our income on an unnecessary bidding war with other (profit-oriented) search engines. We'd rather use it to plant trees on our endangered planet.
We also believe that it is unethical for a company with a dominant market position like Google to discriminate access to that market by artificially limiting user options, thereby creating scarcity where there is none.
In short, this “choice screen” is not a choice screen at all and is harmful for competition. So what should Google be doing instead?
Google should show a fair and open list, which ranks search engines based on their relevance to users, not on their willingness to pay to be seen. To be completely fair, this list should be unlimited and not preselected. Each search engine would have a description so users could make an informed decision based on their own preferences.
We, along with other alternative search engines, will continue to talk to the European Commission to advocate for fair competition in the search market. More news to come - watch this space!